Bewitched Halloween Cheese Board

Bewitched Halloween Cheese Board

Make All Hallows’ Eve deliciously dramatic. This festive collection leans into Halloween’s classic colors—vivid pumpkin-orange cheeses paired with crisp, dark-ready wafer crackers—so the board looks as seasonal as it tastes. Four distinctive orange cheeses bring tang, cream, caramel, and nutty depth. Add the included wafers, finish with Spanish dark chocolate and almonds, and the night goes from savory to sweetly haunted.

What’s inside

Vat 17 Cheddar by Deer Creek

Award-winning world cheddar with a rich orange hue and a bold, tangy-nutty bite. Aged for sharpness so it stands up on a spooky spread.

Ingredients: Pasteurized milk, salt, cultures, enzymes.

Dietary: Contains milk. Vegetarian-friendly (microbial enzymes). Gluten-free.

Lake Effect by Blakesville Creamery

Soft-ripened goat’s milk cheese with a creamy melt and a gentle tang, plus light citrus and earthy notes. A brighter, hauntingly elegant contrast to the firmer cheeses.

Ingredients: Pasteurized goat’s milk, cultures, rennet, sea salt.

Dietary: Contains milk (goat). Gluten-free.

Jake’s Aged Gouda by Stoltzfus Family Dairy

Bright orange farmstead gouda with toasted-caramel sweetness, nuttiness, and a satisfyingly dense bite. The crowd-pleaser of the haunted feast.

Ingredients: Cultured raw cow’s milk, salt, enzymes.

Dietary: Contains milk. Not vegetarian (animal rennet). Gluten-free. Made from unpasteurized milk.

Mimolette 12 Month

The pumpkin of the board: deep orange from annatto, firm and flaky, with nutty, caramelized flavor. Slice it thin and watch it disappear.

Ingredients: Pasteurized cow’s milk, salt, lactic cultures, rennet, annatto (color). Some wheels may also include lysozyme (from egg).

Dietary: Contains milk. May contain egg. Typically not vegetarian (animal rennet). Gluten-free.

Natural Wafer Crackers by Rutherford & Meyer

Light, crisp wafers that let the cheeses take center stage—the “black” half of your orange-and-black board.

Ingredients (classic Natural wafers): Wheat flour, cheddar cheese (pasteurized milk, dairy cultures, salt, microbial rennet), rice bran oil, salt.

Dietary: Contains wheat/gluten and milk. May contain traces of soy, sesame, peanuts, and tree nuts.

Blanxart Dark Chocolate Bar with Almond

Rich Spanish dark chocolate studded with crunchy almonds—the sweet spell after the savory course.

Ingredients: Cocoa, sugar, cocoa butter, almonds, vanilla. May contain traces of milk, other nuts, and soy.

Dietary: Contains tree nuts (almonds). Ingredients are typically dairy-free; produced on lines that may handle milk. Gluten-free.

Allergen & diet snapshot for the box

Contains milk, wheat/gluten, and tree nuts (almonds). May contain egg (Mimolette), soy, sesame, and peanuts (crackers/chocolate traces). Not vegan. Not fully vegetarian. Not gluten-free unless a gluten-free wafer is substituted.

Please note that any item temporarily out of stock will be substituted with a similar item of equal value.